Loyalty

In response to:
Are You Loyal to the Party?

LS mentions two bothersome things about hirelings:
1) "I hate seeing them treated as props. As things that can be safely ignored until a player wants them to make an attack, or use an ability."
2) "I also hate determining a hireling’s loyalty when they are first hired, and having that number remain static throughout their tenure with the party. A person’s loyalty to their employer should be a function of their working experiences, not an innate attribute of their character. Loyalty should be a thing that goes up and down constantly, depending on how valued the retainer feels, and how much of a future they see for themselves in this work."

Here's how I'd prefer to set up dynamic (between session) loyalty:  Use a 2d6 roll:

2d6:	Result
2	-2 loyalty
3-5	-1 loyalty
9-11	+1 loyalty
12	+2 loyalty

• If the roll is 3 or more below current loyalty, subtract an additional -1 loyalty.
• If the roll is 3 or more above current loyalty, add an additional +1 loyalty.
• Modify by PC's charisma modifier
• Additionally modify by the following:
• PC pays very well:  

Reasoning:

• The +/-3 on current loyalty is because it shouldn't be easy to change the status quo.
  The reason for the additional modifiers is that even if things go well