Skip to main content

RPG Carnival: Beyond Vancian Magic Wrap-Up

 

 


Hello Friends!

It was a blast to host RPG Blog Carnival's 2024 year-end topic, Beyond Vancian Magic! Thank you all so much for your input!  In no particular order, here's what some of you shared as your response to the topic, along with attempts at summaries:

  • Robgoblin kicks things off with Skills for the Magic-User.  Starting with propositions for turning read magic and detect magic into skills, then suggesting some innovations with counterspells, upcasting, and harsher spell recovery to bring wizards closer to linear power progression.
  • Xaosseed shares a spell point and spellburn system of magic, which briefly talks about the system Xaosseed uses to add more risk to magic when magic-users run dry, and shares a wish list of what the perfect magic system would have.
  • VDonnut Valley gives us Beyond Vancian Magic - Wizards of Sword of Don II, which talks about magic of the culture in the wake of the fall of the Bronze Towers of Marano.  Where once wizards knew hundreds of spells, they are now down to about twelve well-known spells.  On the balance, though, wizards are not as dependent on spell books as under Vancian magic, and while preparing spells is slightly more difficult, they can even prepare spells multiple times a day, and try to prepare more spells at a time with a risk system.
  • Learning Magic in Glimmermark shared how learning magic works in the Glimmermark setting. It also discusses the philosophy of magic-user guilds in the Glimmermark, including an example of a guild, the Spiegelheim Guild of Spellweavers.
  • Sailing the Stygian Sea has a thoughtful and elegant framework for magic. I'm loathe to do injustice to it by attempting to summarize it: Beyond Vancian Magic: Applied Arcana.
  • In Miracles of the Forgotten Gods, Alone in the Labyrinth shares a post about mechanics for manifesting miracles, explaining how high priests, prophets, and saints (living or dead) influence these manifestations differently from normal folk.  Wonderful food for thought!
  • On a Swamp in Space shares a post called Troika, Jojo & Superpowers, discussing wr3cking8a11's Second Sun game's magic system, taking inspiration from Troika, but also more-flexible and chaotic skill-based systems such as DCC and GLOG.  These systems treat magic more like super-powers, and how wr3cking8a11 takes inspiration from anime sources, including Jojo's Bizarre Adventure.
  • Over on Tabletop Curiousity Cabinet, in Beyond Vancian Magic: Goetia for adventure games, Panic Pillow re-imagines some LBB spells using a simple recipe system that makes every spell a simple recipe that requires preparation of physical components.  I love that each spell also has a taboo that nullifies or inverts the spell effect.
  • Robgoblin follows up with The Magic of Poetry, a more magically open system.  I wonder if there's ground there to make an OSR bard that doesn't just feel like a weak and thief-ish magic-user.
  • Due to the carnies' extravagant new year's celebrations, Salad was able to sneak in a last post in the Bommyknocker Press blog, Anti-Spells and Lost Humanity, which talks about slot-based spells (like Mausritter), and also the concept of anti-spells, a way for magic-users to give up one's humanity to make room for more spells.  I'm just going to sum with this quote from the post:
"Obviously this is a contentious practice in the wizarding community. Everyone denies it, but everyone at the top is doing it. There are various methods in vogue for masking the effects of anti-spells in social settings."
 

Thank you all for sharing your wonderful magic system-related ideas!  This will probably carry me at least half way through the year!

Tags: #RPGBlogCarnival #OSR #Resource


Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

On Names

  Note : There are a lot of external links in this post. None of them should be affiliate links If they are, please let me know . Note2 : This has been bouncing around in my brain informally for a while, but putting it to pixel was prompted by Rook’s post on names on Beneath Foreign Planets as part of the RPG Blog Carnival .  There’s a lot of great material that comes from these prompts. I encourage you, dear reader, to check that out. Note3 : Link to the GDoc version this post was originally composed in. On Names One of the holes new Game Masters fall into while playing D&D-esque games is names. I’ll start with random NPC names first, to get the subject out of the way:  Make a d20 or d100 list of names for each gender, and for families.  Either stick it on the fourth panel of your DM screen, or pre-roll five of each, and stick those lists on your fourth panel. If you need a list of real world names, use an onomastikon .   Onomastikon “What is an on...
2 comments
Read more

RPG Blog Carnival: Beyond Vancian Magic

  Hello Friends! I'm thrilled to be hosting December's RPG Blog Carnival topic, Beyond Vancian Magic ! I'm not a hater, but I'll admit I prefer different systems being different, and clerical and magic user magic systems are basically the same.   I'm looking forward to seeing your interesting takes and contributions on evolving past that kind of magic system.  While I chose this topic about half a year ago, it's come up recently on r/osr, in the post Vancian Magic - What It Is How It Works and Where Did It Come From? Here are some ideas to get you started if you don't already have something in mind: Creating entirely new magic systems, or emulating those of other works, such as those by Brandon Sanderson or Jim Butcher. Spellcasting based on the undead turning table, as illustrated by ktrey of d4 Caltrops suggested using in Alternative Spell Casting . Expand on existing the existing "Vancian" system: Make spells truly Vancian, so that they a...
5 comments
Read more

How I Generate Home Brew Fantasy Towns Quickly

I was prompted to write this by an article about world building  ( https://ofdiceanddragons.com/rpg-carnival-world-building/ ). One of the challenges of a  gamemaster (GM) is spending time building things that are useful in play.  From that  point of view, after sketching out the world in thirty words, it seems more productive to me to focus on the places the player characters are most likely to go.   Generally, for a sandbox style exploration game in the West Marches style, I want it to be some sort of town or small city.  A village is too small to do more than provide food and fodder, and maybe shelter in a farmer’s barn.  A large city can be an interesting setting, but is probably a little too large for a new GM to start with, even though it basically extrapolates on what’s outlined here. Why? In our elf games, we typically focus on going to wild or hostile places to bring something back or handle a threat.  We don’t really spend much time in ...
Post a Comment
Read more